The SEO professionals are getting confused with using of titles and H1 tags for a better result. People are asking in Google Webmaster Help if the title and the H1 (header) tag need to be identical. The answer to this question is to have consistent not identical. It would be fine to write exactly the same titles and H1 tags in Google News but not with normal Google web search. It is recommended to use a close one with the original title and H1 tag.
People can even use more explanatory but shorter headline in accordance to stories. One can even use keyword based title to deliver a result of the topics looking by the searchers in search engines. Though, the titles and H1 are often used consistently but should not be identical. People writing content should test and see what work amazingly for them. Further, it should be used according to the ranking and users on the web.
Using the title and headline more or less the same helps users to identify the page they came searching from the result pages in the search result. Though, a title is the main result element but the headline is only visible to the users landed on that page. The title needs to be found out by the users on a page. So, too much difference in title and headline often irritate the visitors.
One can use the same keywords in titles as well as in headlines to make sense to the visitors. It is always recommended to show the same topic to visitors for which they came searching in a page. Hence, it is beneficial to use two or three main keywords at a given page and optimize for the better result in a web. This is why; Google is recommending the SEO professionals to optimize title and H1 for maximum result.